The saddle of life Yuri Sidorenko

"Preimuschestvo.Ru" continues to speak about them because the lawyers recognizable words. This genre - "the saddle of life" - for the first time was presented in the PQ magazine Esquire. Vdogon for Barshchevsky

Misha, Olga Egorova, Pavel Astakhov, Yuri Chaika, Alexander Konovalov, Anton Ivanov, Vyacheslav Lebedev and Alexander Gusev, we give a reader a decent lawyer quotes the Russian Federation Yuri Sidorenko - referee of the Supreme Court, Chairman of the Board of Arbitrators PQ. Yuri Sidorenko, 66, lives and works in the capital.

On early childhood, family education, school

I can not say if Wotan guardians of my training over hunted, and sometimes not to the same extent. In addition, after all, and the founder, and his mother worked, and as sure in any of the old working family, a lot of me to give tarry not had a chance. (Magazine "Arbitrator", October 2005)

The main process of civic education in those times was in school. But his own contribution to the creation of persons have made street, the environment in which the child is hovering outside the building and secondary schools. (Magazine "Arbitrator", October 2005)

Secondary education I ended up in a master-Technical School, and afterward it was acting as an electrician at the completion of the Leningrad factories. (Magazine "Arbitrator", October 2005)

The choice of specialty

We have a share [in the emergency service in the Group of Russian troops in Germany] was formed typical "brotherhood" of several inhabitants of the capital and Leningrad. Once we started talking about who is allowed to assume an intelligent, qualified person. And someone said, ideologically, if these properties gives a person a legal education. As you know, we began to argue, but the seed was sown in his heart. And among the other 3 of Petrograd came to our company lawyer department of the Leningrad universtiteta. (Magazine "Arbitrator", October 2005)

About Istok judicial businesslike

It was 30 years old, and I remember not only the occurrence of any case, this decision would, however, including the names of all accomplices in the process - from prosecution for witnesses. (Magazine "Arbitrator", October 2005).

Woman abducted in the store a bottle of brandy. She was closely conviction, and I declared the maximum punishment under the Criminal Code. You know, I would at this time closer to the position of the judiciary and everyday skoplennogo experiment such extremism according to the woman did not show. (Magazine "Arbitrator", October 2005)

In life, we must say, I have a lot of that does not love, I can flame up, flare up, get out of themselves, rather than later on regret, but the court itself could not been seen. (Magazine "Arbitrator", October 2005)

On the qualities that are inherent in the arbitrator shall be

The arbitrator must possess all the qualities that give a person an advantage dignify noble. And together with the fact some special properties, which have all the chances and missed at a noble man, an adept of justice must be characterized by all means. Perhaps, before this is only capacity to subordinate all doubt, nothing can not take for granted as a given and recheck everything. (Magazine "Arbitrator", October 2005)

On the court decision

The arbitrator often perceive the conclusion in spite <...> public conception. He occasionally performs with his own legal decision go against all of Wotan. And at least some otherwise seemingly in sight pravosudnoe <...> the public, it would be criminal. A means pravosudnym it does not exist a possibility. (Magazine "Arbitrator", October 2005)

On the appointment of arbitrators and bringing them to disciplinary action

During the 2-s 10-years per year lose their capacity from 50 to 100 arbitrators. Because of the time, probably some time changed the operation of the arbitrators to attract liability, changed her views, and the number discharged from office permanently. Discrepancy means that, if a body fall sports people unworthy. (Rapeseed, March 2011)

It <operation of appointing an arbitrator> far from dignity, but we're working on it constantly. To the chagrin, and competition for the duties of an arbitrator is not too large. Service nepriznatelnaya arbitrator, languid, terrible, plus bad news community. Who wants to spit it? Since arbitrators often append yarlychek Likhodei. Who wants to self might primerivat? Since the estimates are thinking: what might delight - to land a man. Lacking, no pleasure, no way. (Rapeseed, March 2011)

Before we go against contradicted the proposed amendments to the creators of [presidential corrections to the laws "On the status of referees," "On the Judicial System" and "On Constitutional Court", around which raged fierce debate between adherents of the judiciary and the Kremlin] several types of disciplinary action - reproach, ads a lack of coordination of the breech. Though probably due to the referee with little relation State-owned? Half of the arbitrator? Now we introduce the view of caution. Truth is, it was before, although it was not written in the law. If the referee's permission fault can not stop pulling on his opportunities, qualification board carried a warning. Afterward amendments voprosets of disciplinary arbitrators will presume that way because, as before. However, the process of applying caution must begin disguised: not wanting to be profaned in the arbitrator the power features of its status. ("Entrepreneur", November 2001)

How soon will spend some reform, it is expected to change if something in the top-end side. In fact introduced bills lacks nothing, though could strengthen the authority of the court, judicial independence. As if they can attract graduates of institutions for young lawyers? At this point an attempt is made to give the slope toward the consolidation of self-control and responsibility. But out in front: all the interested face is given a sign, if allowed to go against the arbitrator will settle provocation. The creators did not directly about this rumor, however, received their instructions would specifically like that. ("Entrepreneur", November 2001)